Trying to buy a Godzilla game

Was thinking about picking up one of the sixth gen Godzilla fighting games for a few bucks and went looking to find which is preferred. Reviews gave higher scores to the first game, but their main complaint about the second was "too similar", so I was looking at fan feedback. So far I have found these extremely helpful and well-informed recommendations:

In an Amazon review of Destroy All Monsters Melee: 
"This is the best Gamecube game ever. But it is much more than that. It is quite possibly the GREATEST SINGLE GAME EVER CREATED IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND."

You can't argue he's not level-headed.

In a thread asking which is better, Destroy All Monsters Melee or Save the Earth: 
"All Godzilla games suck and fail beyond everything. Get Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World." 
The OP responded that he was not looking for an RPG, but a giant monster game, so the same poster added: "Giant monster games always suck. I’ve never seen one that DOESN’T suck. Try a different genre."

Not a great troll, as no one could possibly believe that a human being has enjoyed Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World, the second worst JRPG ever made. Nor would a human, even a psychopath, suggest that JRPGs are a universally recommendable genre. Nice try though.

Anyway, probably'll get Save the Earth. Sure as hell not bothering with the motion-controlled Unleashed for Wii.